EVELYN  TIDMAN Author
  • HOME
  • My Art
  • Over the Sea to Skye
  • Blog
  • ONE SMALL CANDLE
  • GENTLEMAN OF FORTUNE
  • REBELLION
  • FOR THE KING
  • Reviews
  • About Evelyn Tidman
  • Contact Me

Historical Research: Some Challenges of Reading Old Texts

1/19/2015

3 Comments

 
PictureA page from Roger L'Estrange's 'Vindication'
A large part of our work as historical writers is research. Original documents when they come into our possession are like treasures to be enjoyed. But deciphering them can sometimes be quite a headache.

Beginning my current work in progress, an as yet unnamed sequel to For the King, or if you like, the further adventures of Roger L’Estrange, I was delighted to discover a booklet written (and printed) by Roger himself in 1649. It's amazing what you can find on Amazon! So, filled with excitement, I sent for it. But no 'look inside' here! So I was not quite sure what I was getting.

When it arrived, I realised I had set myself a task and a half. It is a facsimile copy of the original. but the print is also smudged, badly so in places. In other places it is so faded as to be unreadable, and all but impossible to guess the words. Odd spots or blots also turn up on it. But then, it is from an original copy, so one must expect these things. 

The type itself is sometimes ordinary size, sometimes small, sometimes capitals, sometimes italics. Colons and semi-colons turn up almost every couple of words and in places where a comma or full stop would have done the job. Some sentences are incredibly long, so that I lose the thread. Words we no longer use send me to the on-line dictionary. But even the good old Oxford English Dictionary was confounded by 'accompt', which I guess from the context means something like 'account'. However that doesn't seem to fit the context in this sentence: 'Upon this Accompt, I haftened back, and gave this Iffue to the difpute'.  The nearest the dictionary came to that was a French word meaning 'deposit', which could, at a stretch, fit the context. 

Add to that, Roger was a Latin scholar (he knew five or six languages) and so the text is liberally peppered with Latin sayings. If anyone can tell me what 'Stultorum Bethl'em; Nebulonum, Regia Bridewell: Vtrum [Utrum?] barum mavis, Ingrediare, licet' means, I shall be eternally grateful.

As if that were not enough, as you probably noticed from a quote above, most of the lower case Ss are Fs, upper case Us are Vs, and some times the Ws are VV. Strange spellings too. Such as ‘phancie’ (fancy) and ‘neceffitie’ (necessity). I puzzled over a word, which looked like ‘falure’ (and so I thought it was ‘failure’ which did not fit the context) only to discover it was ‘salute’! The lower case Ts are so small and smudged, they often look like Rs. 

Old fashioned terms come into it. Anyone know what ‘oyer and terminer’ is? No? Well, it’s a legal term, I discovered, regarding a specially appointed court. And the same court jury returned a verdict of ‘ignoramus’. No, that does not mean the defendant was an idiot! It comes from ‘ignorant’, literally, ‘we don’t know’, or the case 'not proven'. May Google be forever blessed!

When I am trying to pick out the facts and events, it makes the job much harder, so I’ve decided the only recourse is to type it out in full, with modern spelling and modern punctuation, so that I can make sense of it. 

I was fortunate. Roger had this booklet printed. Handwritten documents are a bigger challenge, and I feel for those writers dealing with them. Yet at the same time, I rejoice. For there is nothing quite like getting your eyes on original documents.



FOR THE KING Roger L'Estrange and the Siege of King's Lynn is OUT NOW!
Available on Kindle and print
CLICK HERE TO BUY

Picture
3 Comments
carol hedges link
1/18/2015 05:49:24 pm

I don't envy you one bit! I have to say, as a writer of 'Victorian' fiction, I have it comparatively easy..original texts are usually printed, and although some of the wordage is a little obscure, at least it is readable. What I lament ( as I'm sure do you) is the dearth of evidence of ordinary/poor people's everyday lives. I have Mayhew ..invaluable source, but apart from Dickens, who sometimes exaggerates there is little written in the vernacular....

Reply
Evelyn Tidman link
1/18/2015 11:37:01 pm

I agree, Carol. So much has been lost to time. Still, we can only work with what is available. Thank you for your comment.

Reply
Gregory Carter link
11/2/2022 03:10:36 pm

There nothing compare establish manager write hard science. Goal difficult room help.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Evelyn Tidman, the author of REBELLION, Roger L'Estrange and the Kent Petition, the second in the Roger L'Estrange series; FOR THE KING, Roger L'Estrange and the Siege of King's Lynn, the first in the Roger L'Estrange series based on a true story of the English Civil War, GENTLEMAN OF FORTUNE, The Adventures of Bartholomew Roberts, Pirate. a historical swashbuckling romance; and ONE SMALL CANDLE The Story of William Bradford and the Pilgrim Fathers.  All based on true stories.

    Archives

    September 2016
    August 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    October 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    September 2013
    June 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013

    Categories

    All
    Beliefs Of The Pilgrim Fathers
    Pilgrim Fathers
    Pirates
    Pirates' Articles
    Swearing
    Why Bart Roberts

    RSS Feed

    Historical Fiction News - Sign up for our newsletter

    * indicates required
    Picture
    OUT NOW!
    Kindle and print 

    Through Amazon (click to view)
    Picture
    KINDLE AND PAPERBACK
    through Amazon (click to buy)

    Picture
    KINDLE AND PAPERBACK
    through Amazon (click to buy)
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.